Same moves or same results?

[whiplash]

Maybe this has been settled before; but I'm too lazy to search all the threads.

What is the protocol on reloads?

Example from just now in a future game:

I bomb enemy city, result "some population died". Next is a kill and we have kill bug.

I reload and make same moves. This time "we shot down an enemy interceptor". The guy leaves the game instantly. He said nothing before leaving.

I reload again. The guy says he's entitled to leave the game if the result isn't the same upon reload. He even says I should disband the bomber. I think he should abandon the sam. Now this is no noob. He's been on the ladder nearly as long as myself.

I think that players should do same moves and live with the results, EXCEPT when one of those players intentionally leaves after the results.

[jack]

is just about fairplay..

since is not always possible to obtain same results, usually ppl disbands units or things like that..

in your case whip i say just: reload, u bomb, everything happens is ok..

[EviLAiR]

One time I had this very issue with a guy that was going to die he was sumeria and game dropped . . .

I was told that there is no such rule that requires this . . . it is more of an ethical thing

Whatever you want to be known as I guess

[rodrigom]

jack said:

is just about fairplay..

since is not always possible to obtain same results, usually ppl disbands units or things like that..

in your case whip i say just: reload, u bomb, everything happens is ok..

I disagree on that. If on previous sav u bombed him and killed SAM, he need disband his SAM. If ur bomb got killed, disband ur bomber. If u pillaged road, tell him to pillage it. Not fair do something different just cuz some droped (or forced one after lose his sam in a bomb )